is it justified to compare muralitharan with shane warne ?

in many think tanks and cricket pandits of cricket, their view is that muthiah muralitharan is a better or atleast an equal spinner to the great shane warne, i have never agreed to this opinion and i have always said that this is all stupid, shane warne is the best ever spinner the world of cricket has ever seen, there have been great spinners like muthiah, kumble, abdul kadir and many more but warny is a class cant be acheived, mr murali can take 800 test wickets, but when he faces a talent like sehwag, lara or ponting he is always below par, what sehwag done today with murali by smashing him 119 runs of 19 overs, he wud nt be able to do it with warne, murali has taken 250 wickets out of his 700 playing zimbabwe and bangladesh, warne has only played one test against zimbabwe out of his 145.

Chosen Answer:

Murali is top class buddy.Lara/Tendulkar had done same to Warne what sehwag did to murali today.Nobody is immortal.At the end of day they are all humans.

SL,Are they the Best agaist Spin?

I wonder how they couldnt when they practice against 3 out of the best 5 spinners in the world.
(My best 5-1)Murali
2)Harbajan
3)Mendis
4)Herath
5)Vitory
Do u agree wyt Ma best 5 spinners?If not name them pls

Chosen Answer:

AGREED!! but only for test matches
FOR ODI matches everything is right EXCEPT THE FACT DAT MENDIS shouldnt be dere,he is a young kid who still has a lot to achieve b4 he can be classified as one of the best spinners.maybe in a time of 5 yrs, i will agree to dis.i think graeme swann should be included( for ODIs and T20s

AND indians are the best players of spin.LOOK at the records of murali and warne in india, dey uk dismal compared to the overall record